| Platinum | Lucy's Pizza Parlor |
| Gold | Michael's Italian Pizzeria |
| Silver | Mario The Baker |
| Bronze | Lucy's Piza Stillwater Ave. Stamford, Ct |
| Top Pick | Colony Grill |
| Top Pick | Hope Pizza Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Nick's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Remo's Brick Oven Pizza |
| Top Pick | Table 104 |