| Platinum | Lunch Lady Gerri's |
| Gold | Cafe Silvium |
| Silver | Tutta Pazzi |
| Bronze | Belltown Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Bedford Street Diner |
| Top Pick | Mario The Baker |
| Top Pick | Pellicci's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Sorrento Pizzeria & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Sunny and Frankies |
| Top Pick | Trips Restaurant |